• 0 Posts
  • 9 Comments
Joined 16 days ago
cake
Cake day: November 5th, 2026

help-circle

  • The Soviet Union and modern China are not really interchangeable in the way you are attempting though. China’s reforms were in direct response to the material conditions and external constraints coupled with lessons learned from looking at the Soviet Union, western capitalism, Marxism, and their own internally developed political, cultural, and economic theories. It would be like simply equivocating Objectivist economic policies with Keynesianism and saying the failure of the former is transferrable to the latter. Maybe they both have shared flaws present to the overall mode of production they are under, but we have to ID those. And lets also keep in mind that in the development of capitalism that started in the late 1400’s and early 1500’s, capitalist failed repeatedly for over a century. Retreating back into feudalism.

    But let’s also not bastardize history.

    The Soviet Union went from a backwoods peasant society, enduring a civil war and 2 world wars where, along with China, they endured an outsized level of destruction and destabilization from those wars.

    And within decades had one of the highest increases in life expectancy, largely solved homelessness, built nuclear weapons, and put people into space.

    But faced as their adversary the wealthiest nation in history that thanks to that same set of wars, and maintaining their military projection and industrial capacity in tact, with post war control over the wealthiest European colonial powers, used that leverage to strangle the USSR and help compound internal political issues to fracture and collapse it.

    One has to ignore those crucial lurking variables in order to make the sort of neutral economic comparisons you are alluding to.

    As for China… Of course China thrived under neoliberal global capitalism, it had no alternative! That doesn’t though disprove those larger points. If the argument is that China can only thrive like they are under neoliberal global capitalism, good news for China, cause if the OP’s suggestions are adhered to, that won’t be a concern. Hence my whole point about needing to confront the structural and imperialist realities as they are, cause protectionism alone while trying to keep the same system propped up is not going to alter the underlying economic relationships and without other changes is just attempting to paper over these larger issues they aren’t fully confronting.

    A lot of countries have been forced into western neoliberal global capitalism, in fact everyone has, only China has managed to produce the China miracle. Like the OP, might be that we should do less fearmongering, defense-forcing, and have a little more humility, introspection, and a willingness to learn.

    And frankly, if neoliberal capitalism and bourgeoise democracy is the best humanity can do, given it’s put us on a path and accelerated making this planet uninhabitable by humans, that is a dire condemnation for our species IMO


  • I look forward to 2028 when Skydance releases the sad-soldier movie about the lasting trauma from this courageous raid.

    Where their platoon, while putting on the underwear of the ‘terrorists’ they just bombed, were startled by a lone surviving (terrorist)child. Who with weaponized tears in their eyes(tricking our heroes into empathy) flew into a life threatening fit of rabid arab rage and threw his plastic toy at the soldiers. Forcing our hero, played by Adam Sandler, to quickly Krav Maga the kid to the ground(which the movies has established is the coolest and most effective real world combat style). Giving him just enough time to pull out his sidearm, look the kid in the eyes, and do a defensive triple tap.

    People will talk about how Sandler’s performance is Oscar worthy, but I think his co-star Gal Gadot will shock people.


  • America is showing no signs that they are going to buck historical precedents of declining empires and peacefully accept the inevitable multi-polar, non-hegemonic future. Let alone use the current power it has to help establish a post American hegemony world that is more equitable, just, and stable then the one it inherited.

    China is a threat insofar as Westerners remain unwilling to confront the possibility that a more centrally planned market economy, which subordinates private capital to broader state-directed development goals, can outperform neoliberal bourgeois capitalism.

    Nor will they confront the reality that complaints about China’s low-cost goods and labor protections cannot be adequately understood simply as a aberration or merely reflective of a flaw in the moral character of the CCP relative to the superior values of the west. Refusing to examine the exploitative relationships inherent to capitalism such as between capital and labor, the imperial core and periphery, and the constraints imposed by decades of Western-dominated neoliberal globalization that Canada gladly played their role in.

    A system deliberately structured to outsource production, exploit cheaper labor, weaken organized labor at home, and transfer the costs of accumulation onto the periphery while Western capital retained control over finance, intellectual property, and the most profitable segments of these global supply chains.

    The irony is that Western elites spent decades constructing and profiting from this system, only to rediscover their concern for workers and fair competition when another country began successfully challenging their dominance within it.

    The author is right to recognize that economics and human rights are inseparable, but then refuses to follow that insight to its logical conclusion wrt to the system of asymmetrical global capitalism and imperialism as a whole. And in doing that the author comes away with half measures and solutions that attempt to put guardrails around trade and preserve their place in the global hierarchy instead of actually pursuing positive sum policies that would confront and transform the underlying relationships of exploitation and dependency that created these problems in the first place.


  • Right now America and Israel are putting everything in place for another round of escalations to this war with Iran

    Complete with dusting off the Iraq War manufacturing consent playbook and not even bothering to change much of anything

    TBH, if this were a cyberattack it would probably be a gift to the regime, so that is why I lean in the direction of just incompetence and/or something else internally. If this was a cyberattack you would both imagine the people that did it would take credit and the regime would be using it to manufacture consent and deflect blame.


  • Depends on what that system looks like and how it is phased in to know how much or how little.

    But yes, one of the actual issues in decommodification of things like this is that despite what capitalists will argue, it creates greater efficiencies so on net some people will be let go.

    Personally that is why if I were benevolent dictator I would go the New Deal/China style route.

    You couple things like M4ALL with additional industrial policy and investments that help absorb those sorts of shocks that left to just the capitalist market would result in concentrated and severe backlash combined with capital strikes and intentional overreactions and threats from the private sector.

    In reality though I think America will just keep patchworking this shit heap of a system as we have done before and the question will be how well it gets patched up will come down to how much pressure the left can build up. Same way the New Deal happened.


  • TBH I also think that feature can become it’s own problem too.

    The Fediverse may be good at combating certain forms of enshittification(it’s too small right now to know for sure), but what qualifies as such can easily drift into ideological balkanization, purity testing, and arbitrary in-group/out-group policing…Which I already see happening here during my short stay.

    And social networks thrive and grow on cross-community connectivity, discovery, and engagement, excessive ideological sorting and fragmentation then undermines that. That is a core contradiction in the Fediverse that I am not sure is easily reconciled.

    Where the incentivizes toward that balkanizing also increases the risk of creating a network even more unfriendly or overwhelming to newcomers to navigate(ideological boundaries they didn’t create, didn’t consent to, and may not even understand), while risks decreasing broader political dialogue, coalition-building, and productive disagreement that makes town square social media what it is and not just a more convoluted Discord for messageboards.



  • Honestly? Cause much of the entirety of the US tech capitalist model is just digital feudalism.

    Create a compelling reason to join your digital kingdom then when enough people move there you put up the enclosures and start profiting off exploiting your subjects and charging tolls to people wanting to access them.

    And ideally enough of that peasantry remain dependent on your digital commons that realistically they can’t leave.

    The upside is that this process naturally lends itself toward enshitification over time. The downside is that unlike messageboards of old, social media deploys incredibly addictive algorithms to keep a core type of user engaged. And then those habits harden and leaving feels impossible.