

Blaze had calculated that at some point. It was quite awhile ago so that could have changed radically since then but… based on all of my personal experience things seem to mostly be moving in the opposite direction. e.g. as mander.xyz and slrpnk.net are both down (hopefully just temporarily), and smaller communities struggling mightily hence people remain in the biggest ones.
If there are multiple “active” communities of the same type on different instances, I tend to block .ml, .world, and .social communities (with the goal of helping de-centralization). So, I don’t have a good understanding of what an un-curated experience is like.
One example is !tenforward@lemmy.world retaining 5.77K MAUs compared to its offshoot !tenforward@piefed.world with just 0.08K MAUs.
I think a more equitable comparison would be with !risa@lemmy.dbzer0.com, that has “2K Monthly Users”.
We cannot support much niche content so it generalizes instead. The trends towards centralization are not being counter-balanced as much as previously by trends away from that.
In the short term, I don’t see this as particularly problematic, as long as the communities are dispersed across instances (helps congregate activity / seem more active).
Again, there was a huge shift to try to spread them around, but that was before the Flotilla began threatening to split the Threadiverse in two in consolidation with anarchist.nexus, and I for one tend not to post into communities located on dbzero anymore (I am not like morally opposed to such, but I just don’t try to prioritize it as I once used to).
… virtually a guarantee to happen if any single member of the Flotilla ever gets defederated from, I think this one not merely by LW but by any instance whatsoever, anywhere. That is no mere threat about some future vote that may or may not happen - that is outright policy, a settled matter, iirc.
I take the opposite view of that event. I see the flotilla as protecting against an authoritarian action by the .world admins, in the same vein/idea as “Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”. I have no faith the .world admins would have stopped at anarchist.nexus or would in the future.
That is probably due to your having blocked a lot of it?
Definitely possible. In a slightly related tangent, it looks like Piefed copied Pylova’s user block lists, but implemented them in an incompatible way. Also, possibly breaking instance conversion from Piefed to Pylova. Ugh…
That assumption might not be true. If the Flotilla defederates not merely from LW but from any instance that remains federated with it, then the schism would be wide indeed. But we’d have to read more the Flotilla policy to see (again) their stated aims. I forget the likelihood of this being true, but it’s definitely nonzero and more than just a vague conspiracy theory - whether it actually happens or not, people were most definitely clamoring for exactly that to occur, and it was not a fringe opinion iirc. Then again, after the cooling period, things probably will look different, so most likely the most extremist opinions will be drowned out by those wanting the greater convenience of remaining connected.
My recollection is that defederation would only happen to instances that de-federated from a member of the flotilla (like .world). De-federating from anyone that federates with .world would be massive self sabotage (in my view). Hopefully, that’s not what happens.


My block list is probably doing me many favors in regard to those.
Yeah, I think getting more instances to institute an initial user-level instance block for the “triad” instances (like .zip) may be the best return on effort, at this point.
I recalled the Star Trek communities splintered, but didn’t remember the specifics.
I think we might have been discussing different points. It seems, to me, you may have been talking about Lemmy vs. Piefed and I was talking about Plurality/Flag-ship instances vs not.
Yeah, not many people holding Piefed’s ‘water’ at this point.
I don’t know that we will still be like this in a decade, I still consider the Threadiverse to be at a ‘Beta’ version level (maybe ‘Alpha’). As bad as it may look at times, we aren’t losing users faster than we are gaining them, actually +3.8% compared to a year ago).
I like that you brought the games community up, it seems like that is the only area right now big enough to host a variety of more niche active communities (ex. tabletop, patient gamers). So, might be the closest to breaking out into more singular communities (ex. !cyberpunk2077@lemmy.world, but possibly GTA6 will be the first majorly active one, assuming it’s not already and I’ve blocked it).
I’m going to still disagree that, if it were to happen, it would not be the flotilla causing it. In my view, the entity causing the response is the responsible party (like if Russia invaded a Baltic country and NATO declared war on Russia, Russia would have caused the war, not NATO).
Possible I haven’t seen those discussions due to my blocks.
I like your analogy. Never heard of the “free trader and pirate ships” version (flotilla == pirate ships, I’d guess).
Well said.
Yep… :(
Yeah, my thoughts exactly. Plus breaking the Piefed -> Pylova conversion, seems to me Rimu is trying to wall his garden.
I was expecting much worse, based on what you were saying. I see where you’re coming from, but I don’t think posting or writing about a guillotine is that radical. I think most people don’t think the law works and isn’t likely to justice for the leaders/rich/whatever that are abusing/imprisoning/torturing/murdering/genociding people in broad daylight. So, not surprising to me they would call back to one of the well known times that those types of people got “justice”.
Another way you may want to consider is, what’s the difference between beating someone to death, starving them to death, poisoning to death (via tainted drinking water), withholding lifesaving medicine (ex. cancer treatment), or working someone to death. They all lead to death, usually just on different timelines and with different levels of direct interaction.
If a CEO jacks up the price of life saving medicine 1000% and now 10,000 people can no longer afford it and they die, did that CEO kill them? Some may say no, others may say yes. If the answer was yes, then if some random rich person is killing thousands a day/month/year/whatever, and the law will likely never touch them, what should someone do? If the only answer people give them is vote every other year, and hope that something that has never happened in their live happens, I don’t think many tempers will be quenched and people will search for and call for other solutions.
As in they checked it out and ran away screaming?
“religious” is an unexpected inclusion. I almost never run into anyone religious IRL or online. “centrist” is also a curious point, who’s “centrist” (American, European, Canadian, South Pacific, other; they are all different)? I think your environment may be affecting your viewpoint here.
Edit: New community you might want to check out: !blocklists@cozyver.se