• 0 Posts
  • 455 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle


  • Portability is not really an aspect one needs to consider when it comes to a NAS

    Hard disagree, and it is one of the best things about ZFS. You can plunk a ZFS pool on another system and be almost certain it will import. Systems die. Having been through several data-loss incidents, I find it is much preferable to be able to pull 1 disk than have to drag out 2 or three to transplant a ZFS pool.

    Regarding the scrubs, I was trying to indicate that ZFS is more than just a raid manager, there are advantages to ZFS on even a single disk.

    for a home NAS, the goal is maximising data storage capacity without a major hit on performance

    If that were entirely true, striping would be the most popular ZFS pool arrangement, since you get performance and max storage.

    Edit: this was not to say “you’re wrong”, just different approaches to storage.











  • Gate-keeping is a strong word… It also implies that people on the other side of the gate learned something to get there.

    20 years ago we were doing what we could manually, and learning the hard way. The tools have improved and by now do most of the heavy lifting for us. And better tools will come along to make things even easier/better. That’s just the way it works.

    Compare self-hosting to doing your own mechanic work on a vehicle: there are a lot of tasks that most ppl would benefit from learning the diy way to do it, but there are dangers to car repair that will never go away, like proper car support with jacks, securing wheels correctly, etc.

    It would be neglectful for the community to say nothing and send ppl off to get pwned.


  • My range to the next node is 7 miles.

    Lucky you. I’ve got max about 900m (about half mile) by putting a node up on the mountain near me, and that was intermittent and message transmissions were delayed between 5 and 10 min.

    Like I said, great if it works. Not a whole lot of good use cases, and op’s is not a good use case.


  • AirTags work because there is a huge network of apple devices registering BT beacons. Meshtastic isn’t really viable unless there are other nodes around on the same channel, as you mentioned.

    I have tried to use two LilyGo t-echos to GPS track my dog. Range is really poor in the mountains, so I basically couldn’t see the collared device unless it was within 100 to 150m away, which isn’t really helpful.

    In a bigger urban area, more nodes didn’t help unless I was on the default channel, so same problem again, this timeline extra emf pollution.

    Meshtastic is a great idea, but use cases are really limited.